Analysis of a case of 42yr old female with multiple health events since birth

I've been given this case to solve in an attempt to understand the topic of "patient clinical data analysis" to develop my competency in reading and comprehending clinical data including history, clinical findings, investigations and come up with a diagnosis and treatment plan. 

You can find the entire real patient clinical problem in this link here... https://classworkdecjan.blogspot.com/2019/05/42-f-with-severe-regular-edema-with_17.html?m=1

Following is my analysis of this patient's problem:

The major problems encountered by the patient include:
1.Headache
2.Swelling over face and abdomen
3. Reduced sleep
4. Cognitive impairment
5. Reduced exercise tolerance
6. Reduced urination and sweating

 HEADACHE :
  • Since the age of 2 yrs
  • Gradually progressive 
  • One sided mostly the left
  • Frequency : 2times / week (in summers) 
  • Lasts for long duration (sometimes upto 3 wks) 
  • Aggravated on : emotional stress, hot climate, when sick
  • Relieved on medication :Triptans
  • Associated with : visual aura (in the form of mild cresent light to severe as blindness lasting for 2hrs) ,preceeding inflammation on the scalp, preceeding spinning movements, stuttering, left side hemiparesis. 
This description led me to diagnosis of Hemiplegic migraine. 
But further investigatios are required to confirm the diagnosis. 
Investigations required:
  • CT/MRI of head 
  • Familial Hemiplegic Migraine genetic testing
Treatment : continue with TRIPTANS
                      avoid stress and hot climates. 
                           

SWELLING:
  • mostly on the face and abdomen sometimes involves even gut, hands and feet
  • Since birth 
  • Imtermittent
  • progressess by the end of the day ( from noon to evening) 
  • Aggravated on : food ( high carbs, fava beans) , emotional stress ,  smoking(swelling occurs after 1hr of smoking) , exercise and diuretics
  • Relieved on : fasting, rest (1-3 wks) , Cimetidine
  • Associated with : SOB, reduced urination
From the above details I probably think that the swelling is due to ANGIOEDEMA. 
My points of explanation for this are:
 Firstly there is underlying G6PD deficiency (which I will elaborate later) and her aggravating factors ( food, smoking, exercise) cause release of ROS , these ros cause stimulation of inflammatory substances like histamine in mast cells and also membrane instability leading to angioedema. 
Investigations required: 
   Skin test and blood test(C1 estarase inhibitor) 
Treatment : Cimetidine
                      avoid triggering factors. 


REDUCED SLEEP:
  •  Since birth
  • 2-4 hrs /day
  • No REM sleep
  • Sleep improved with L-Serine 20 mg (6-7 hrs /day with REM sleep of 3 1/2 hrs) [L-Serine improves sleep initiation and reduce night awakening]
This reduced sleep can be due to reduced NADPH and reduced Glycine. 
Treatment : continue with L-Serine


COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT :
  Like BIPOLAR DISORDER , ADHD (Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder).
Probable reasons could be :
  • Lack of sleep
  • ANKK1 mutation
  • Hyper homocysteine
  • Behcets disease (? ) 
Treatment : 
        CBT (cognitive behavioral therapy) 
         Avoid stress factors by doing performing some       activities that distract you from worries. 


REDUCED EXERCISE TOLERANCE :
   Severe post exercise swelling , early fatigue. 
 Swelling could be due to release of ROS (as said above) and fatigue due to AMPD1deficiency(explained later) as stated from her genetics. 
Rx : D-Ribose (which helped her) 


REDUCED URINATION AND SWEATING : 
   Severely reduced urination, thirst and sweating when swelled up and improved when her swelling subsided. 
Also she takes a lots and lots of salt. 
Probable mechanism : 
         kidney needs lots of energy for ions active transport and hence water balance in body and her urge for salt as when she might be loosing them heavily, also a reason may be why she urinate less is because she loose lots of ions as not having enough nadph & atp for their absoption by active transport mechanism. 
Rx : L-Serine , cimetidine helped her
        Fasting helped her a lot ( but I do not suggest for     complete fasting ). 



As mentioned in her genetics , there is G6PD deficiency , AMPD1 deficiency and hyper homocysteine they fitted into the cause for most of her complaints. 

G6PD DEFICIENCY :
  It is an X-linked inborn errors of metabolism that predisposes to red blood cell breakdown. 
Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) is an enzyme in the pentose phosphate pathway (also known as the HMP shunt pathway). G6PD converts glucose-6-phosphate into 6-phosphoglucono-Ξ΄-lactone and is the rate-limiting enzyme of this metabolic pathway that supplies reducing energy to cells by maintaining the level of the reduced form of the co-enzyme nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH). The NADPH in turn maintains the supply of reduced glutathione in the cells. Reduced glutathione is required to maintain and protect the RBC membrane from ROS. 

Thus deficiency of G6PD lead her to hemolysis, paleness, fatigue, jaundice, tachycardia, dark urine, SOB. 

Triggers : 
     viral/bacterial infections, drugs like antimalarial and sulfa drugs, fava beans, exercise, alcohol, smoking, stress, lack of sleep, high carbs diet. 

Investigations suggesting this  is her genetic testing for G6PD gene.

Rx : 
  • Avoid triggering factors (drugs, foods,...) 
  • Supportive treatment
  • Vit B12 and Folic acid supplements
  • NAC (helps in building antioxidants) 


AMPD1 DEFICIENCY : 
 Adenosine monophosphate deaminase deficiency, is an inherited disorder of muscular energy metabolismwith lack of AMP deaminase activity in skeletal muscle. 
Normally, AMPD catalyze the deamination of AMP that which leads to formationof fumarate via purine nucleotide cycle and this fumarate is an intermediate in Krebs cycle that finally required in ATP production.
So the deficiency of AMPD leads to reduced ATP production. 
As the patient genetic study and her exercise intolerance and fatigue on exertion are suggestive of AMPD1 deficiency. Moreover her response to D-Ribose was very satisfactory. 
Rx : 
      continue with D-Ribose(0.1-0.15 mg/kg/hr) . 



HYPER HOMOCYSTEINE : 

Homocysteine is an amino acid not supplied by the diet that can be converted into cysteine or recycled into methionine, an essential amino acid, with the aid of specific vitamins like B12, B6, Folic acid. 


Elevated levels of homocysteine can increase the risk of atherosclerosis by causing endothelial layer injury, promoting inflammation, and increasing oxidative stress. However, the exact mechanism is still unknown, and more research needs to be done to identify the pathophysiology. In relation to brain atrophy and cognitive decline, the correlation with elevated homocysteine levels is unclear but has been speculated to be a finding related to vitamin deficiencies. 

Factors in favour of her developing hyper homocysteine include signs and symptoms of Vit B12, B6 and folic acid deficiency like weakness, fatigue, mood changes, SOB etc also Other diseases that correlate with elevated homocysteine levels include hip fracture, cognitive decline, osteoporosis, chronic kidney disease, hypothyroidism, Alzheimer disease, and schizophrenia.

Rx: 
     low homocysteine diet
     Bit B12, B6, folic acid supplements. 


BEHCETS DISEASE : 
She was recently diagnosed wit behcets disease she said. 
BEHCETS DISEASE is an autoimmune disease associated with systemic vasculitis and immune complex deposition. 

Complaints suggestive of her having behcets disease include: 
  • Mucosal ulceration
  • Skin lesions
  • Rashes on face 
  • activation of warts and EBV(? ) 
  • obscuration of vision and led to blind for which lasik failed. 
Rx : she is on Colchicine (but there is possible risk of   hemolysis in G6PD). So I prefer her to shift to cytotoxic   drugs. 


OTHERS :
Her other health events I could not explain throughly :

  • VWF Disease type 1 : cause for easy bruising and dark stools, menorrhagia. 
  • WNK1 mutation : PAH2 (high BP, anhydrosis, hyper kalemia) . 
  • Raised ICT followed by CSF rhinorrhea for 10mins at the age of 35.
  • Menorrhagia, with clots, ectopic pregnancy, excessive hair growth on face/neck/toes &legs, hairloss on scalp are explanatory for PCOS. 
  • Fluctuating BP (high with fava) POTS, difference in both arms. 
  • Hyperinflation of lungs and H/O  smoking suggestive of COPD but further evaluation needed. 
REFERENCES: 
2.Wikipedia

Comments

  1. [5/16, 10:08 PM] Rakesh Biswas: There is a lot of copy paste here that you haven't referenced in text. Just saying Wikipedia doesn't count as reference. Check out how to properly cite wiki articles in text. Anything that you need to quote needs to be mentioned in "..." and one can't quote more than one or two lines.
    [5/16, 10:09 PM] Rakesh Biswas: When you edit your document please don't delete anything. Just mention edited at date time and then add the new information.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anusha:

    Hello sir,
    I'm student of 8th sem,
    I have a doubt sir that in AMPD1 where AMP deaminase is deficient then the pathway should shift towards producing Adenosine which is an inhibitory NT that should cause sleep.
    But the pt. (from Dr. Avinash blog) was sleepless.

    RB: What is the specificity of that genetic test?

    In how many individuals who test deficient for that gene will we see actual deficiency of AMP deaminase?

    Very good question πŸ‘You get one point for it and you will get one point if you can answer the above

    ReplyDelete
  3. [5/16, 1:30 PM] : Tq sir
    I will try to find it out and report to you sir.

    [5/16, 1:58 PM] +91: Can't find the exact numerical sir, but came to know that vast majority of them are asymptomatic.

    [5/16, 7:32 PM] Rakesh Biswas: Very good. So do we really need to worry about her AMPD1?

    [5/16, 9:37 PM] +91: Yes sir because she is showing the symptoms of muscle weakness and easy fatigue.
    It is not necessary that every symptom should fit in I guess!

    [5/16, 9:37 PM] +91: Also her genetics showed AMPD1 DEFICIENCY

    [5/16, 9:40 PM] +91: Also evidence of D-Ribose helping her to get rid of her exercise intolerance

    [5/16, 10:03 PM] Rakesh Biswas: What is the specificity of that genetic test?

    [5/16, 10:04 PM] Rakesh Biswas: Can we call it an evidence if it is not randomized and blinded?

    [5/16, 10:06 PM] Rakesh Biswas: So if vast majority of them are asymptomatic and this patient belongs to the minority with symptoms, how severe are her symptoms? Is she bedridden? Is she unable to perform her normal functioning? Unable to work?

    ReplyDelete
  4. This log book is now shown to the anonymized patient and the following active learning conversations pasted below are with the online patient whose data this and 200 other student logs have tried to analyse:


    [5/16, 1:27 PM] Rakesh Biswas: Your case history has gotten our students reading a lot πŸ™‚πŸ‘

    [5/17, 3:52 AM] Online patient: Isn’t caffeine a non-selective adenosine antagonist for A1/A2A receptors? Wouldn’t low adenosine from a deficient mimic chemical antagonism?

    [5/17, 7:04 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Get ready for large number of e logged feedback now on your previously e logged patient data. Have been having a spate of active learning these few days with the students around your case.

    One of the biggest issues with your data is that most of them are crumbling on deeper scrutiny and will need better digging by asking you about those areas that are crumbling.

    I had since the first time when I saw your data set it aside for this very reason but when I got the opportunity to bounce it with an entire class I realized it could be useful for us to again start looking at your data critically


    [5/17, 7:05 AM] Online patient: πŸ‘

    [5/17, 7:05 AM] Rakesh Biswas asking the student who made this log: So if vast majority of them are asymptomatic and this patient belongs to the minority with symptoms, how severe are her symptoms? Is she bedridden? Is she unable to perform her normal functioning? Unable to work?


    [5/17, 7:05 AM] Student: Yes sir that she mentioned that even brushing her hair is difficult sometimes


    [5/17, 7:06 AM] Online patient: No one with AMPD is bedridden that I know of

    [5/17, 7:06 AM] Online patient: It impacts fatigue to exercise or exertion


    [5/17, 7:07 AM] Online patient: For me there is no question on this being an issue as it’s genetically viable- matches others in the support groups and is improved notably with the addition of D-Ribose


    [5/17, 7:09 AM] Rakesh Biswas: πŸ‘yes most doctors are used to seeing more severe weaknesses and are unable to connect to relatively milder (invisible) ones (from the doctor's perspective) while the patient continues to suffer especially also because no one is able to appreciate their suffering

    [5/17, 7:09 AM] Online patient : Missing a single dose makes a huge negative impact as happened last winter when our car broke down and I had to walk miles to the nearest ranch to get assistance. Pain the entire time and then for 3 days following and then had a flare of skin issues

    [5/17, 7:11 AM] Online patient: Taking ribose no pain during or after exertion- unless I go for a long time (10pkus miles hiking up a mountain for example) then have some soreness but that seems expected in most.

    [5/17, 7:11 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Yes but again we don't have (by current cruel definitions) hard core EBM data to support it in terms of diagnostic sensitivity specificity and therapeutic efficacy. Will be great if our students help us in finding those though.


    [5/17, 7:12 AM] Online patient: Genetic test is 100% accurate and AMPD mutation is seen in 2 different test

    [5/17, 7:14 AM] Rakesh Biswas: If only we could have done an 'n of 1' trial here we may have been able to nail the efficacy of ribose for at least one patient.

    It would involve someone blinding the patient to if she is taking ribose or placebo (very carefully for the patient to not realize it at all including masking the taste etc) and run it for two cycles with and without ribose and voila.

    I feel this is the ideal patient for an 'n of 1'

    [5/17, 7:15 AM]: It’s studied well for AMPD1


    [5/17, 7:16 AM] Rakesh Biswas: How do we know it's 100% accurate to predict disease characteristics? I guess you meant 100% accurate in terms of showing mutation which is understandable.

    ReplyDelete
  5. [5/17, 7:16 AM] online patient :

    We know of many studies. http://www.myobase.org/index.php?lvl=notice_display&id=41246#.XsCXU-QieaM


    [5/17, 7:16 AM] Online patient : An error would not show the same mutation over 4 genetic tests



    [5/17, 7:17 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Yes I am not questioning it's accuracy in predicting mutation



    [5/17, 7:18 AM] online patient : It’s the only thing that fits phenotype and is remedied by what is scientifically shown to help.


    [5/17, 7:19 AM] Rakesh Biswas: What is the correlation between a genetic mutation and disease pattern in terms of causality? How do we ensure that the mutation causes the disease pattern you are describing. This is the moot very fundamental and hence most challenging query here


    [5/17, 7:21 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Yes the question is what is the percentage correlation between this genotype and your phenotype? In 100 people with your phenotype how many would show AMPD mutation that is the question


    [5/17, 7:21 AM] Online patient : Not everyone with AMPD has issues- some don’t think the my have issues at least but under exercise tolerance test show issues. If your life norm is one way- you may just assume everyone feels the same things you have since birth.


    [5/17, 7:21 AM] online patient : AMPD is one of the most common enzymatic issues in 5% of the population.


    [5/17, 7:23 AM] Online patient : “It is not known why some people with this condition do not experience symptoms. Researchers speculate that additional factors, both genetic and environmental, may determine whether a person develops the signs and symptoms of AMP deaminase deficiency.” From the rare genetics site



    [5/17, 7:23 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Very valuable input.

    This means if we look at it the other way, AMPD mutation positive genotype no characteristic phenotype. So the genotype expression is heterogeneous as also you pointed out because of the individual characteristic as the same individual with the AMPD carries other genes that another AMPD carrier doesn't

    [5/17, 7:23 AM] Online patient : It’s not a deadly disease so limited study


    [5/17, 7:24 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Yes so your "n of 1" trial becomes even more important.


    [5/17, 7:24 AM] Online patient : Worth note- those in my family diagnosed with fibromyalgia all have AMPD1 mutation (mother and a cousin)


    [5/17, 7:25 AM] Online patient : This seems common in the AMPD group


    [5/17, 7:25 AM] Online patient : Many are diagnosed with fibro but later found AMPD1 in their genetics


    [5/17, 7:26 AM] Online patient : Interestingly “fibromyalgia” also seems to be helped by D-ribose.


    [5/17, 7:27 AM] Online patient: An intersting overlap? Or are people being diagnosed with this mystery muscle pain disorder actually patients with AMPD1?

    [5/17, 7:29 AM] Online patient: https://patents.google.com/patent/US6703370B1/en


    [5/17, 7:29 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Needs efficacy trial?

    [5/17, 7:29 AM] Rakesh Biswas: Is there a trial done or it's just a patent for the hypothesis?


    [5/17, 7:31 AM] Online patient : https://accpjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1592/phco.24.16.1646.50957?sid=nlm%3Apubmed


    [5/17, 7:31 AM] Online patient : There are some clinical trials underway.

    [5/17, 7:31 AM] Online patient : This is just a case report. No one does full genetics when doing trials


    [5/17, 7:31 AM] Online patient: Should be the norm IMO


    [5/17, 7:33 AM] Online patient : Anecdotally there is some evidence of overlaps in support groups but that is not backed by real study data


    [5/17, 7:35 AM] Rakesh Biswas: So let's see if we can get some real studies done by first finding out who we know lives near you

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts